Charles Ponzi’s postal promise met a Boston investigation
Charles Ponzi built his Boston investment business around a real postal product: the international reply coupon. The coupons were intended to pay for return postage across national borders. Ponzi claimed that differences in currency values offered enormous profits, and promised investors returns of 50 percent within 45 days. His payments came instead from money supplied by later investors. In 1920, the business collapsed under investigation, leaving thousands of people with losses and turning his surname into a lasting description of financial fraud.
Ponzi arrived in the United States from Italy in 1903. His early years involved a succession of small jobs and moves between cities. He also went to Montreal, where a forged cheque brought a conviction and imprisonment. A later conviction in the United States followed his involvement in bringing immigrants across the Canadian border unlawfully. Before his Boston fame, his life had already included both ordinary employment and repeated encounters with the criminal courts.
In 1917, Charles Ponzi returned to Boston for clerical work. He married Rose Gnecco the following year and attempted several businesses, including a grocery operation and a proposed trade publication. The journal failed to attract the bank financing he wanted. By late 1919, he was promoting a different enterprise from an office on School Street. The Securities Exchange Company presented the reply-coupon business as the source of its extraordinary returns.
International reply coupons solved a mundane problem in overseas correspondence. A person sending a letter abroad could include a coupon so the recipient could obtain stamps for the reply. The coupon was exchanged for postage, rather than being an investment certificate. After the First World War, changing currency values made the international system look attractive to Ponzi. His advertised profits, however, depended on a trading operation that did not exist at anything like the required scale.
Charles Ponzi attracted customers from several social groups, including factory workers, small traders, police officers and immigrants. Sales agents extended his reach beyond the people he knew personally. A surviving May 1920 advertisement was issued in English, Italian and Portuguese. It gave the company's address as 27 School Street and promoted an agent in Plymouth, where an office opened during the evening. The publicity carried the same short-term promise to readers in several languages.
Early payments encouraged confidence and further deposits. Many customers left their supposed earnings with the company instead of withdrawing them. Ponzi bought a large house in Lexington, expensive cars and interests in other businesses. His holdings included commercial and rental properties in Boston. He also acquired a stake in Hanover Trust, a bank that had previously refused to finance his publishing idea. The growing display of wealth existed alongside liabilities to investors that exceeded the underlying assets of his enterprise.
The Boston Post began reporting on him in July 1920. At first, the newspaper described the spectacular rise of the man offering such high returns. Its subsequent work challenged the finances behind the publicity. Postal investigators also examined the operation. The legitimate volume of reply-coupon business could not support the profits he advertised. The postal explanation had supplied a plausible technical vocabulary for a company whose real cash flow depended on continuing deposits.
On 26 July, Charles Ponzi agreed to stop accepting new investments while officials examined his books. Investors then crowded his office asking to be repaid. He made repayments and tried to reassure the people waiting outside, while newspapers continued covering the affair. The examination exposed a shortfall of millions of dollars. The attempt to demonstrate stability had become a public crisis involving customers, banks, auditors and criminal investigators.
His arrest was followed by federal mail-fraud proceedings. In November 1920 he pleaded guilty and received a five-year prison sentence. Massachusetts also pursued charges, leading to further imprisonment after state proceedings. While on bail during that later phase, he went to Florida and became involved in a land-selling venture that produced another conviction. He eventually returned to Massachusetts custody. In 1934, after his release, he was deported to Italy.
The Boston Post received the 1921 Pulitzer Prize for Public Service for exposing his operation through its reporting. Ponzi later moved to Brazil, where he worked for an airline and, after that employment ended, as a language teacher and interpreter. He died in Rio de Janeiro in 1949. His second cousin, Italian Air Force officer Attilio Biseo, had helped him obtain the airline position. That work lasted from 1939 until December 1941, when Brazil cut off supplies after learning that the airline carried strategic supplies to Italy.
- US Postal Inspection Service — Organized crime and illegal schemes: Charles Ponzi — www.uspis.gov
- Mass Humanities — Ponzi scheme begins to unravel — www.massmoments.org
- Smithsonian Magazine, Mary Darby — In Ponzi we trust — www.smithsonianmag.com
- The Pulitzer Prizes — The Boston Post, 1921 Public Service winner — www.pulitzer.org