Urschel kidnapping: the Memphis arrest behind a gangster's name
The Urschel kidnapping carried investigators from an Oklahoma City bridge game to a Memphis residence and an Oklahoma federal courtroom. George Kelly, born George Kelly Barnes and widely called Machine Gun Kelly, was one of the men charged in the federal case. His capture on September 26, 1933, ended a search across several states. A surviving court commitment dated October 12, 1933, recorded a prison term lasting for his natural life.
Kelly had been involved in illegal liquor sales before the kidnapping. A National Archives account describes his use of the name George R. Kelly and a bootlegging business after an earlier marriage ended. A 1927 arrest for selling liquor on an Indian reservation brought a three-year sentence at Leavenworth. After his release, he married Kathryn Thorne. The couple's criminal reputation became inseparable from the prosecution that followed Urschel's disappearance.
On July 22, 1933, Charles and Berenice Urschel were entertaining Walter Jarrett and his wife at their Oklahoma City home. Kelly and Albert Bates interrupted the bridge game and abducted both men. Jarrett returned after the kidnappers released him outside the city. Urschel remained in captivity while his family and its representatives received ransom demands. The payment ultimately amounted to $200,000. The bureau's case history records Urschel's arrival home on July 31.
After the Urschel kidnapping, the released oilman gave investigators a detailed account of his confinement. Among his recollections were the sounds of farm animals, a noisy well, and aircraft passing at regular times. He placed the flights at approximately 9:45 in the morning and 5:45 in the evening. He also remembered heavy rain on July 30 and the absence of the usual morning aircraft.
The bureau compared his recollections with airline schedules and weather records. Its published history identifies the Fort Worth–Amarillo service of American Airways and the vicinity of Paradise, Texas. Airline records recorded a storm delay and a changed route on July 30. Weather Bureau records from Dallas recorded rain around Paradise on that date after a prolonged dry period. Investigators also established that Kathryn Kelly's mother lived near Paradise, connecting information about the suspects with Urschel's description.
At the Texas properties, Urschel identified houses and people associated with his confinement. The bureau also described his recognition of a small chair, a bucket, a cup, and the well. Bates was arrested in Denver on August 12, 1933; some currency in his possession was identified as ransom money. Other arrests and proceedings followed. Larry O'Dell's account for the Oklahoma Historical Society records that the wider case eventually produced twenty-one convictions, rather than a prosecution confined to the Kellys alone.
George and Kathryn Kelly were still at large while other defendants faced proceedings in Oklahoma City. They were arrested in Memphis by federal agents and local police on September 26. The bureau's case history records their convictions and life sentences on October 12. The National Archives reproduces George's commitment form from the federal court's records, identifying the case as U.S. v. George and Kathryn Kelly. Its caption dates the document to the same day as the sentence.
The original commitment belongs to Record Group 21, the records of the United States district courts. The National Archives described the indictment, verdict, and commitment documents for both defendants when those materials were displayed in 2012. The reproduced form names George R. Kelly and states the term as natural life. The documents came from the National Archives at Fort Worth.
Motion pictures also became part of the Urschel kidnapping record. National Archives specialist Richard Green described a collection of eight films associated with federal district court cases from 1933–1934. The Urschel film contains both reenactments of the crime and footage from the trial. Staged reconstructions accompanied moving images of actual courtroom proceedings. Green identified the trial as the first federal courtroom proceeding to allow movie cameras.
Kelly's supposed surrender cry acquired a separate history. In a 2008 review, the FBI compared the familiar phrase about G-Men with its earliest account, written within several days of the arrest. That account described Kelly standing in a bedroom corner with his hands raised while a Memphis police sergeant covered him. It recorded no speech by Kelly. The bureau therefore treated the famous quotation as doubtful, tracing its development through later newspaper coverage and the work of reporter Rex Collier.
The Urschel kidnapping nevertheless became associated with the growing public image of federal investigators. The FBI's historical review notes the success of the film G-Men in 1935 and the spread of related entertainment and toys. Kelly's remaining life was spent in prison. He served seventeen years at Alcatraz, returned to Leavenworth in 1951, and died in custody in 1954.
- FBI, George ‘Machine Gun’ Kelly: Urschel investigation and convictions — www.fbi.gov
- Larry O'Dell, Urschel Kidnapping, Encyclopedia of Oklahoma History and Culture — www.okhistory.org
- National Archives at Kansas City, April 2012 newsletter, page 3: Kelly's original commitment — www.archives.gov
- Richard Green, National Archives, Gangsters, G-Men, and Archivists — unwritten-record.blogs.archives.gov
- FBI, The Legend of ‘Machine Gun Kelly’, September 26, 2008 — archives.fbi.gov