A Think Again Media Group publication
Name That Culprit

Willie Sutton’s wanted picture reached the right subway passenger

Willie Sutton’s wanted picture reached the right subway passenger

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Updated · Name That Culprit

Willie Sutton’s wanted picture reached the right subway passenger

Willie Sutton was recognised on a New York subway in February 1952 by a tailor's son who had seen his wanted picture. The bank robber had escaped from prison in Pennsylvania five years earlier. His photograph had been distributed to tailors as well as police departments because he was known for expensive clothes. The passenger's report led New York City police to arrest one of the early members of the FBI's Ten Most Wanted Fugitives list.

Born William Sutton in Brooklyn on 30 June 1901, he was the fourth of five children. He left school after eighth grade and held jobs as a clerk, driller and gardener. His criminal career brought the nicknames Slick Willie and the Actor. The second referred to the disguises he used during robberies. He later co-authored two books, I, Willie Sutton and Where the Money Was, giving his own account of a life that had become nationally recognisable.

A 1934 robbery of Philadelphia's Corn Exchange Bank brought a sentence of 25 to 50 years at Eastern State Penitentiary. Sutton had already been imprisoned and escaped before entering that institution. At Eastern State, he attempted escape at least five times. On 3 April 1945, he joined 11 other prisoners in a tunnel escape from Cellblock 7. Philadelphia police caught him within minutes, only two blocks away. All 12 men were eventually returned to custody.

The escape was chiefly the work of Clarence Klinedinst, a prisoner who repaired masonry around the institution. Sutton later claimed public credit for its design and construction. Klinedinst's cellmate William Russell was among those who emerged with him. One escapee, James Grace, returned voluntarily early on 11 April, ringing the prison doorbell and asking to be admitted because he was hungry. Klinedinst's capture added another three to six years to his sentence.

The prison Willie Sutton had tried to leave belonged to an earlier experiment in punishment. Pennsylvania authorised funding in 1821, following advocacy by the Philadelphia Society for Alleviating the Miseries of Public Prisons. Architect John Haviland designed seven cellblocks radiating from a central hub. The first prisoner arrived in 1829. The original Pennsylvania System relied on solitary confinement with labour, intended to encourage penitence. By 1913, that system had formally ended, following decades of increasing shared accommodation and activity. Its original capacity was 250 people, but the population reached about 1,700 in the mid-1920s. Construction continued throughout its working life. By 1956, the original seven cellblocks had become 15, even as Pennsylvania built additional prisons elsewhere in the state.

After the failed escape, Sutton received a life sentence as a fourth-time offender and was transferred to Philadelphia County Prison at Holmesburg. He escaped again in February 1947. In March 1950, the FBI placed Willie Sutton on its new Ten Most Wanted list. His addition came six days after the programme's formal launch on 14 March. Bank robbery was a prominent category among fugitives publicised during the list's first decade.

The programme began with a newspaper enquiry in 1949. A reporter asked the FBI for information about particularly wanted fugitives, and the bureau supplied photographs of ten men. The Washington Daily News printed them on its front page. Public attention helped produce captures, and the bureau established a continuing list the following year. Its publicity combined photographs with identifying information and made the search for particular fugitives a matter of national public attention. Sutton's photograph became one of those circulated beyond police offices.

The recognition on 18 February 1952 occurred when the tailor's 24-year-old son spotted Sutton on the subway. He followed him to a gas station, where Sutton bought a car battery, and reported what he had seen. Sutton did not resist arrest. He subsequently received another sentence of 30 years to life after a Queens County jury trial. He remained in prison until Christmas Eve 1969, when he was released from Attica at 68. In 1970, he appeared in a television advertisement for a Connecticut bank's photograph-bearing credit cards. He died in Spring Hill, Florida, in 1980.

Eastern State also entered a different phase. Pennsylvania ceased its operation in 1970, although the building briefly served as a city jail in 1971. Preservation efforts eventually led to public tours in 1994. Archaeologists excavated the entrance of the 1945 escape tunnel in 2005 and used ground-penetrating radar to establish its route. A painted line subsequently marked that route at the historic site. Klinedinst's initials and the date 1938 survived on the prison's masonry, another trace of the man whose work Sutton had later claimed.

The Question

Which bank robber was recognised by a tailor’s son on a New York subway in 1952?

Show the answer

The Answer

Willie Sutton was recognised from his wanted picture; the passenger’s report led to his arrest.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the first one” you agree to Name That Culprit’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.