A Think Again Media Group publication
Name That Culprit

Butch Cassidy’s Wyoming pardon did not end his outlaw career

Butch Cassidy’s Wyoming pardon did not end his outlaw career

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Updated · Name That Culprit

Butch Cassidy’s Wyoming pardon did not end his outlaw career

Butch Cassidy served a prison term in Wyoming before becoming the best-known member of the Wild Bunch. Entered under the name George Cassidy, he arrived at the penitentiary in Laramie in July 1894 as inmate 187. His conviction concerned stolen horses. Within 18 months, a pardon returned him to freedom, supported by the judge who had sentenced him. The later train and payroll robberies followed that release, rather than preceding a long career of repeated prison sentences.

He was born Robert LeRoy Parker in Beaver, Utah, in 1866, the eldest of 13 children. The family moved to Circleville in 1879. As a teenager, he worked on ranches and encountered Mike Cassidy, a ranch hand involved in livestock theft. Parker later adopted Cassidy's surname. After leaving home, he moved through ranch work in Utah, Colorado, Wyoming and other western states. Two cowhands who became close associates were Elzy Lay and Matt Warner.

The Wyoming prosecution involved more than one allegation. Cassidy and Al Hainer were charged in Fremont County in 1892 with stealing a horse belonging to the Grey Bull Cattle Company. They maintained that they had bought the animals without knowing they were stolen. A jury acquitted both men in 1893. A further case involving different horses produced a different result the next year: Cassidy was convicted, while Hainer was again acquitted. Judge Jesse Knight imposed a two-year sentence.

Douglas A. Preston represented Butch Cassidy. A lawyer who had moved to Wyoming in 1887, Preston had already helped frame the new state's constitution at its 1889 convention. His later public offices included service in the state legislature and two terms as attorney general. Cassidy's friendship with him continued beyond the horse cases. Preston also represented Warner in a later Utah prosecution, linking the lawyer's work with several members of the same loose circle of cowboys and offenders.

In September 1895, Knight wrote to Governor William Richards asking that Cassidy be pardoned. The judge was concerned about mistakes in the trial's treatment of knowledge that the horses were stolen. Local officeholders supported the request, including sheriffs, the mayor of Lander and other Fremont County officials. Richards visited the penitentiary in January 1896 and spoke with Cassidy. A pardon followed that month. Cassidy had served approximately 18 months of his two-year term.

The prison used the Auburn system. Men worked in groups but were expected to remain silent, wore striped clothing and were identified by numbers. Construction had begun in 1872, and the institution admitted its first prisoners in January 1873. Initially a federal prison, it became Wyoming's state penitentiary after statehood. Cassidy's confinement therefore took place in a territorial-era building that had acquired a new administrative role, rather than in the later state prison at Rawlins.

After release, Butch Cassidy resumed crime with associates known as the Wild Bunch. They used a network of remote country across several states, including Brown's Park near the Utah, Colorado and Wyoming borders, and Robbers Roost in southeastern Utah. At Castle Gate in April 1897, Cassidy and Elzy Lay robbed the Pleasant Valley Coal Company payroll. The grand-jury records identify a bag of silver coins among the property taken. Accounts of the total haul differ, as do later retellings of the hold-up.

The gang became associated with Union Pacific train robberies at Wilcox in 1899 and Tipton in 1900. Cassidy's personal participation in those two Wyoming robberies remains uncertain. The Wild Bunch name covered several offenders, and identification of the gang did not establish that every famous member was present. A posse pursuing the Wilcox robbers lost Sheriff Joe Hazen in a confrontation. The search drew substantial railroad resources and national newspaper attention, but the robbers escaped the immediate pursuit.

In 1901, Butch Cassidy left for South America with Harry Longabaugh, the Sundance Kid, and Longabaugh's companion Etta Place. They acquired a ranch at Cholila in Argentina. Later accounts place Cassidy and Longabaugh in Bolivia, where they are commonly reported to have died in 1908. Stories that Cassidy returned to the United States persisted, but no conclusive identification established those supposed returns. William Phillips, a man later associated with such claims, was an impersonator.

The Laramie prison outlasted its most famous inmate's confinement. In 1903, prisoners moved to Rawlins and the University of Wyoming received the property for a stock farm and experiment station. Cells were removed and parts of the building adapted for animals. The university used the site for nearly nine decades. Its surviving prison buildings later became a historic site, preserving the setting of Cassidy's numbered imprisonment and the pardon that preceded his wider notoriety.

The Question

Under which name was Robert LeRoy Parker widely known as a member of the Wild Bunch?

Show the answer

The Answer

Robert LeRoy Parker became known as Butch Cassidy; his Wyoming prison record used George Cassidy.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the first one” you agree to Name That Culprit’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.