A Think Again Media Group publication
Name That Culprit

The crime fighter who collected rewards for his own thefts

Jonathan Wild: the stolen lace and the price of recovery

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Name That Culprit

Jonathan Wild: the stolen lace and the price of recovery

Jonathan Wild's profitable service could end with a victim recovering stolen property while its thief remained at large. In 1725, the distinction became fatal to him. Catherine Statham paid ten guineas to obtain the return of stolen lace through Wild's arrangements. He was acquitted of stealing the lace but convicted on the separate charge concerning payment for its recovery. The business that appeared to relieve theft's consequences was itself the basis of the conviction. Jonathan Wild was hanged at Tyburn on 24 May 1725.

The transaction appears in testimony reproduced in Lives of the Most Remarkable Criminals, a collection first published in 1735 and later edited by Arthur Hayward. Statham described going to Wild after the theft, advertising a reward and returning repeatedly for news. On 10 March, he summoned her to Newgate with ten guineas. His imprisonment had not prevented him from arranging a recovery. A porter carried the money and returned with the box of lace, one piece short. The practical service continued through an intermediary even while its organizer was in custody.

That printed testimony makes an important distinction between the price paid to recover the goods and Wild's presentation of his own remuneration. He disclaimed a personal fee and represented his assistance as charitable. The money nevertheless moved through an arrangement he controlled. The original collection is a commercial criminal history, with a moralizing narrative around the evidence; the attributed testimony is the narrower basis for the sequence of visits, payment and delivery. The narrator's moral judgments extend beyond the events described in Statham's attributed testimony.

The legal rule was already available in contemporary print. Bernard Mandeville's Enquiry into the Causes of the Frequent Executions at Tyburn, published in 1725, reproduces a statutory clause directed at people who took money for helping owners recover stolen goods. The exception required apprehending the thief, bringing that person to trial and giving evidence. Returning property alone did not satisfy the condition. A recovery broker could therefore satisfy the owner commercially while failing the law's demand for prosecution. Jonathan Wild's claim to be useful did not remove that distinction.

Mandeville's argument also shows why the arrangement had customers. He criticized private bargains over stolen property for sheltering thieves and evading prosecution. His pamphlet addressed the interests of owners, intermediaries and offenders together, instead of treating recovery as an uncomplicated public benefit. This was contemporary criticism of the trade, not a judgment delivered in Wild's trial. Its reproduced statute supplies the legal wording, while its discussion identifies the incentive to pay for a quick return and leave the offender available for further theft.

Charles G. Harper's later Half-hours with the Highwaymen preserves another side of the lace prosecution through his reproduction of the evidence. Henry Kelly testified that Wild pointed out the shop and waited nearby while Kelly and Peg Murphy entered as customers. The pair took a box, returned to Wild and accepted ready money rather than waiting for a recovery advertisement. Harper then distinguishes that testimony from the verdict: Wild was acquitted on the theft charge. An accusation recounted by a prosecution witness cannot be substituted for the actual result on that charge.

Harper's treatment also preserves Statham's efforts to raise her offer. She initially advertised fifteen guineas and later indicated she would pay twenty or twenty-five rather than lose the lace. The eventual demand of ten guineas could consequently look economical. Yet the reduction concerned the price of retrieving stolen property, not the elimination of the underlying theft. The contrast between what she was willing to pay and what she was charged helps explain the appeal of Wild's intermediary role without treating gratitude from a victim as a measure of his innocence.

The Dictionary of National Biography places those dealings within a larger organization. It describes an Old Bailey office, branch offices, specialized gangs, warehouses and arrangements for disposing of property abroad. It also records Wild's efforts to obtain public recognition for catching thieves, including his January 1724 petition for the freedom of the City of London. Newspaper publicity presented Jonathan Wild as thief-taker general. That reputation depended on visible arrests, while the profitable recovery transactions depended on his connections to the people who could return the goods.

A later engraving in London Museum's collection fixes that double reputation to a building. Published for the European Magazine on 1 February 1813, it depicts the house in the Old Bailey associated with Wild and describes him as a director of thieves and a receiver. The museum identifies the makers and the paper-and-ink object, rather than presenting the print as an eyewitness image from 1725. By then the supposedly helpful office had become a place associated with organized theft. The lace prosecution supplies the precise transaction behind that reputation: money accepted for recovery, with no corresponding delivery of the thief to justice.

The Question

In early eighteenth-century London, a gang leader presented himself as a crime fighter while returning property his own thieves had taken for rewards. The Privy Council consulted him in 1720, and he recommended raising payments for evidence against thieves. Who was it?

Show the answer

The Answer

Jonathan Wild operated on both sides of the law, running a criminal gang while presenting himself as the Thief-Taker General. His system turned theft, recovery rewards, and the arrest of rivals into parts of the same business.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the first one” you agree to Name That Culprit’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.