Mary Read faced an Admiralty court in Jamaica
Mary Read stood trial for piracy in Jamaica on 28 November 1720, alongside Anne Bonny. The two women had sailed with John Rackham during a campaign of robberies around the Bahamas and Jamaica. Their case brought fishermen, merchant captains and other witnesses before a Court of Admiralty at St Jago de la Vega, now Spanish Town. Both defendants pleaded not guilty. The court convicted them and imposed death sentences, then postponed their execution after they said they were pregnant.
Three months earlier, the crew had taken a sloop from Nassau. A proclamation issued by Governor Woodes Rogers on 5 September named Mary Read and Bonny among the people accused of stealing the William on 22 August. The vessel belonged to Captain John Ham. Other named crew members included George Fetherston, John Davies and John Howell. Rogers listed its equipment as well as its name, including sails, rigging, anchors and a canoe. He declared the crew pirates and enemies of the British Crown.
The prosecution described a voyage through waters used by small working craft as well as merchant vessels. The first charge concerned seven fishing boats near Harbour Island on 3 September. Fish and fishing tackle valued at £10 in Jamaican currency were taken. The next concerned two merchant sloops near Hispaniola on 1 October. Those vessels, their gear and equipment were assigned a much higher value, £1,000, in the charges brought before the court.
Two further attacks brought the crew to the north coast of Jamaica. On 19 October, they took a schooner commanded by Thomas Spenlow near Porto Maria Bay. The following day, they took a merchant sloop commanded by Thomas Dillon near Dry Harbour. The prosecution valued Spenlow's vessel and equipment at £20 and Dillon's at £300. The case against Mary Read covered this succession of attacks, rather than merely her presence aboard a pirate vessel at the moment of capture.
Dorothy Thomas was one of the people who testified. She had been travelling in a canoe with livestock and provisions off Jamaica's north coast when Rackham's sloop took most of her belongings. She identified both women as being aboard. Her description included men's jackets, long trousers and head coverings. Other witnesses described the women changing between men's and women's clothing during the voyage, with men's clothing worn during pursuits and attacks.
Two French witnesses, John Besneck and Peter Cornelian, spoke through an interpreter named Simon Clarke. They placed the women aboard when Spenlow's schooner and Dillon's sloop were captured. They described them as active participants who appeared to be there voluntarily. Thomas Spenlow also identified both defendants. Dillon described losing his vessel and cargo after encountering Rackham's crew in Dry Harbour. The hearings assembled accounts from several people whose ships or possessions had been taken.
The crew's voyage had ended off western Jamaica. Captain Jonathan Barnet attacked their vessel near Negril under instructions from Jamaica's governor. The captives were brought to Spanish Town. Rackham and a group of male defendants went before the court earlier in November, in proceedings separate from the women's hearing. Rackham was executed before Mary Read and Bonny appeared together. Their joint trial therefore followed the conclusion of the case against their captain.
After the guilty verdicts on 28 November, the women asked that their sentences be stayed because they were pregnant. The court ordered a postponement and an inspection. That decision changed the immediate outcome: neither was executed with Rackham's group. Mary Read remained in custody and died in prison in April 1721. Bonny's later life followed a different course, with her ultimate whereabouts remaining uncertain. The two defendants did not share the same recorded ending.
The trial took place near the end of the period commonly called the golden age of Atlantic piracy. Governments combined naval patrols, prosecutions and offers of pardon in their attempts to suppress attacks on trade. Her case involved ordinary commercial property: fishing equipment, small vessels, cargo and the supplies carried in a canoe. The victims and witnesses belonged to the same coastal economy through which the pirate crew travelled.
Publication carried the women's names far beyond Jamaica. The trials were printed there in 1721, and newspapers across the Atlantic reported their conviction. A General History of the Pyrates followed in 1724 and made Read and Bonny prominent figures in pirate literature. Their likenesses appeared in later illustrated editions. Modern portrayals continued the fascination: Read became a character in Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag, while Amanda Cotton's sculpture Inexorable depicted the two women together at a temporary display in Wapping.
- Royal Museums Greenwich — Anne Bonny and Mary Read — www.rmg.co.uk
- Heather Rose Jones, Alpennia — transcriptions of the 1720 proclamation and 1721 trial proceedings — www.alpennia.com
- Library of Congress, Esther Markov — The life and trial of Anne Bonny — blogs.loc.gov
- Royal Museums Greenwich — The golden age of piracy — www.rmg.co.uk