A Think Again Media Group publication
Name That Culprit

A jailbreak before a final encounter at Fort Sumner

Billy the Kid: the court order that kept him in custody

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Updated · Name That Culprit

Billy the Kid: the court order that kept him in custody

On 6 April 1881, a New Mexico court entered an order concerning Billy the Kid under another name: Henry Antrim, alias Kid. The federal indictment was quashed, but the prisoner was not set free. The same order directed a transfer of custody so that a separate territorial murder prosecution could proceed. Preserved in a court record book and reproduced by the National Archives, the entry catches him between two jurisdictions shortly before his conviction and escape.

The violence behind those proceedings had begun years earlier. In 1878, the Lincoln County War set competing commercial interests against one another. Billy the Kid served with the Regulators, whose members killed Sheriff William J. Brady and Deputy George W. Hindman. The Library of Congress places those killings within the conflict between established merchants and their competitors. That setting explains the overlapping armed factions, but affiliation with the Regulators did not remove the possibility of prosecution for an individual killing.

The effort to secure a pardon also had a specific chronology. Governor Lew Wallace's 1878 amnesty excluded people already convicted or indicted, leaving Bonney outside its protection. In March 1879, Bonney offered information about the killing of lawyer Huston Chapman. He met Wallace and agreed to testify. That exchange linked the hope of clemency to cooperation with authorities, rather than to an unconditional release of everyone who had fought in the county conflict.

Bonney gave evidence, but the local prosecutor did not release him. He escaped custody in June 1879. After his later capture, he again sought Wallace's intervention through letters from Santa Fe. Those requests did not prevent the April 1881 trial for Brady's murder. Billy the Kid's dealings with the governor therefore form a sequence of proposals, testimony, continued custody and further appeals. The existence of negotiations cannot by itself stand in for the pardon he wanted.

Capture finally came during Garrett's pursuit in December 1880. James H. East, one of the participants, recalled the operation in a letter dated 1 May 1920, printed in Charles Siringo's History of Billy the Kid. East began by acknowledging the nearly 40-year interval. He described the posse learning that the fugitives had gone to a small stone house at Stinking Spring. The men rode out after midnight, approached before daylight and took positions in the snow close to the single doorway.

In East's recollection, Charlie Bowdre emerged and was shot by Garrett and Lee Hall. A horse was then killed in the doorway, obstructing escape. The posse held the remaining men inside before their surrender. East later helped escort the prisoners towards Santa Fe. These are a participant's retrospective details, including his own place in the operation; their remembered dialogue cannot carry the same certainty as the dated court order that followed the capture.

That order, dated 6 April 1881, records the appearance of defence counsel Ira E. Leonard and federal attorney Sidney M. Barnes. The court sustained Antrim's jurisdictional plea and quashed the federal indictment. It then specified another pending murder indictment under territorial law and directed the United States marshal to surrender him to the Doña Ana County sheriff for trial, with Lincoln County custody also ordered subject to that proceeding. The National Archives identifies the federal case with Buckshot Roberts's killing on an Indian reservation. Termination of that indictment therefore did not dispose of the separate territorial prosecution.

Billy the Kid was subsequently convicted of murder and sentenced to hang. On 28 April he escaped from the Lincoln County jail, killing guards J. W. Bell and Bob Ollinger. The Library of Congress dates the breakout and identifies both men. Garrett killed him at Fort Sumner on 14 July 1881. The sequence runs from capture through a transfer between legal authorities, conviction, another violent escape and death, rather than from a general amnesty to freedom.

The public story continued after Garrett shot him. In 1882, Garrett published an account of the pursuit and death, actually written by his journalist friend Ashmun Upson. The Library of Congress notes both its influence and historians' criticisms of its accuracy and bias. Garrett wanted to correct newspaper and popular-fiction accounts, but his own role in the shooting made him an interested participant. The book is therefore evidence of how the sheriff presented events as well as a source later writers used to reconstruct them.

Billy the Kid's name travelled through different sorts of records: a court used Henry Antrim, a governor corresponded with William H. Bonney, and a commercially published narrative used the nickname familiar to readers. Those documents were produced for different purposes. A custody order determined where a prisoner would be held, while a sheriff's book explained a pursuit to the public. Comparing their purposes keeps the official transfer of April 1881 distinct from the reputation that expanded after his death. The surviving record supports a sequence of legal proceedings without requiring every later anecdote to receive the same authority.

The Question

In New Mexico in 1878, a young outlaw joined a county conflict as a member of a group called Regulators. Captured by Pat Garrett in December 1880, he escaped jail in April 1881 before Garrett killed him at Fort Sumner that July. Who was it?

Show the answer

The Answer

Billy the Kid. Born Henry McCarty and also known as William H. Bonney, he participated in the Lincoln County War and escaped jail before Pat Garrett killed him in 1881.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the first one” you agree to Name That Culprit’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.