A Think Again Media Group publication
Name That Culprit

From a captive sailor to more than 400 prize ships

Bartholomew Roberts: pirate rules and the records of their failure

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Name That Culprit

Bartholomew Roberts: pirate rules and the records of their failure

Bartholomew Roberts commanded pirates under rules that attempted to hold a violent company together. The early printed source for those rules, Captain Charles Johnson's A General History of the Pyrates, also describes his unlikely promotion. A second mate aboard the slave ship Princess, he entered Howell Davis's company after capture and was elected captain within six weeks. Johnson presents the choice as a preference for navigational ability and courage. It was an election within a criminal enterprise, followed by an effort to regulate that enterprise's spoils, discipline and internal disputes.

After Walter Kennedy absconded with a ship and treasure, Johnson says Bartholomew Roberts and the remaining men adopted sworn rules. The printed clauses gave each man a vote on important affairs, prohibited gambling for money and required serviceable weapons. A man losing a limb was promised 800 dollars from the common stock; the captain and quartermaster received two prize shares. Yet Johnson calls his version the substance gathered from pirates' information and says the signed original had been thrown overboard. The surviving text is an early report of the agreement, rather than the original document bearing the crew's signatures.

John Atkins supplies a different perspective. His Voyage to Guinea, Brasil, and the West-Indies, published in 1735, describes service with the naval expedition pursuing the pirates. Atkins records traders' alarm after raids on the African coast and intelligence arriving by canoe about newly captured vessels. Information was uncertain and sometimes contradictory. His ships followed the pirates toward Whydah, missing them by a day before continuing toward Cape Lopez. Bartholomew Roberts appears here through the movement of intelligence and naval pursuit, rather than through speeches attributed to a newly elected captain.

Atkins describes the capture of three ships containing about 200 Englishmen and sixty or seventy enslaved Africans, together with trading goods and gold dust. His estimate of the gold's value was lower than the pirates' own claim. He also records the dispute over its distribution: officers, sailors and families petitioned when the commander received a royal grant. The aftermath of Bartholomew Roberts's enterprise thus involved arguments over confiscated wealth as well as punishment. Atkins's participation gives his observations particular value, while his contempt for the captives and defence of naval discipline remain visible parts of his standpoint.

Another early surviving object is an engraved image of Bartholomew Roberts catalogued by the National Maritime Museum as PAD2721. It appeared in a 1734 folio expansion of Johnson's history and carries the page number 228. The museum identifies an elaborately dressed captain on the West African coast, with an attack on a fort behind him. Its description qualifies the background identifications as presumptions. The print establishes how the pirate was represented in an early publication; it is not a view drawn at the battle. Costume and setting belong to the image's dramatic construction.

The same catalogue connects the pictured Royal Fortune with the captured Royal African Company ship Onslow. Bartholomew Roberts mounted forty guns aboard the prize and renamed it. The museum traces the vessel from attacks at Ouidah in January 1722 to Cape Lopez, where Captain Chaloner Ogle's Swallow found the pirates. Ogle first captured their consort Ranger and then returned against Royal Fortune. Roberts died in the action on 10 February. These ship identifications and movements come from the museum's historical description, separately from what can actually be seen in the engraved scene.

Royal Museums Greenwich's study of Ogle's coconut cup adds the naval circumstances. Swallow carried fifty guns, but disease had weakened her company, while the two pirate vessels together carried seventy-two. On the decisive morning many pirates were still affected by the preceding day's drinking. Bartholomew Roberts was killed by grapeshot, and his men weighted his body and put it overboard. The museum reproduces a Swallow logbook page recording the encounter. That operational record and the early printed crew rules concern different moments: prescribed order within the crew and the naval engagement that ended its captain's command.

Royal Museums Greenwich places the subsequent proceedings at an Admiralty court in what is now Ghana. Fifty-two men were hanged. Eighteen bodies were tarred and displayed in cages as warnings. Its broader history also attributes more than 400 captures to Bartholomew Roberts, a retrospective total rather than an inventory supplied by the engraved portrait. The punishment transformed the surviving crew from a self-governing company into prisoners subject to external authority. The written promise of shares and compensation had offered no protection against the consequences of naval defeat and prosecution.

Ogle's cup preserves the victor's side of that change. Its coconut shell carries a warship, a fouled Admiralty anchor and the Ogle family arms. The museum associates it with the commander's success against Bartholomew Roberts, but explicitly leaves the carver and source of its silver mount uncertain. Ogle received a knighthood in 1723. The cup's identifiable decoration commemorates naval power and family prestige; suggestions that a sailor carved it or that captured pirate silver supplied the mount remain possibilities. The object survives without requiring either attractive explanation to become established fact.

The Question

Forced to join pirates when his ship was captured off West Africa in 1719, this Welsh navigator was elected captain within six weeks. He later took more than 400 prize ships and introduced a pirate code after a crewmate sailed away with his vessel and loot. Who was it?

Show the answer

The Answer

Bartholomew Roberts was the Welsh pirate elected captain shortly after being forced into Howell Davis's crew. His captures exceeded 400 vessels, although most were fishing boats.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the first one” you agree to Name That Culprit’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.