A Think Again Media Group publication
Name That Culprit

Which pirate received a stay of execution after her trial?

Anne Bonny: the witnesses, the verdict, and the pregnancy plea

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Name That Culprit

Anne Bonny: the witnesses, the verdict, and the pregnancy plea

Anne Bonny appears in the surviving Jamaican trial pamphlet under the name Ann Bonny, otherwise Bonn. On November 28, 1720, she and Mary Read stood before a piracy court at St. Jago de la Vega, now Spanish Town. The printed proceedings preserve the charges, witnesses, verdict, death sentence, and subsequent pregnancy plea. They offer unusually concrete evidence of women's participation aboard John Rackham's vessel, while leaving the later course of Bonny's life unresolved. The legal outcome was a conviction followed by a respite from execution, not an acquittal.

The pamphlet was printed in Jamaica in 1721 and survives in the National Library of Jamaica's digitized collection. Governor Sir Nicholas Lawes presided over the commissioners. Anne Bonny and Mary Read pleaded not guilty to four charges arising from attacks around the Caribbean. The allegations named particular vessels, dates, and places, including fishing boats near Harbour Island and seizures near Jamaica's north coast. Their case was heard separately from Rackham's earlier trial. The women's presence in the dock consequently has its own testimony and judgment, rather than merely appearing as a detail in his sentence.

Dorothy Thomas described being intercepted while traveling by canoe with provisions. The pirates took most of her goods. Two women wore men's jackets and long trousers, with handkerchiefs tied around their heads; each carried a machete and pistol. Thomas said the women urged the men to kill her so she could not testify. This was testimony about an armed attack on a civilian and an alleged attempt to prevent identification. It places Anne Bonny in a violent working crew, rather than supplying a decorative exception to an otherwise male adventure.

Other testimony addressed participation more directly. Two French witnesses, John Besneck and Peter Cornelian, gave evidence through interpreter John Clarke. They described the women as active and willing, with Anne Bonny passing gunpowder to the men. They said the women wore men's clothes during chases or attacks but women's clothes at other times. That distinction suggests practical changes in dress aboard the vessel. It does not support a claim that every shipmate remained unaware they were women, or that male clothing alone explains their acceptance among the crew.

Witnesses also connected the defendants with attacks on named trading vessels. Captain Thomas Dillon described a gun in Bonny's hands and the women's readiness for violence. The proceedings record no defense witnesses and no cross-examination by either defendant after the opportunity was offered. The commissioners unanimously found both women guilty on the third and fourth charges. That wording matters: the recorded verdict specifies those charges, rather than declaring every allegation in the four-part indictment separately established. The sentence was hanging, the same capital punishment imposed for piracy in the proceedings.

Only after judgment did Anne Bonny and Mary Read state that they were pregnant and ask for execution to be postponed. The court ordered a respite and an inspection. The printed proceedings stop without supplying the inspection's result. A later statement that pregnancy was medically confirmed therefore requires something beyond this pamphlet. Equally, the postponement did not erase the verdict or become a pardon. The precise sequence was conviction, sentence, pregnancy plea, and delay, leaving a clear distinction between the legal judgment and the timing of its execution.

A General History of the Pyrates, published under Captain Charles Johnson's name in 1724, gives Anne Bonny a much fuller personal history. It includes childhood and relationship stories, dramatic behavior in battle, and a memorable farewell to Rackham. Those scenes are absent from the trial testimony. The book also says she received repeated reprieves and was not executed, while admitting that her later fate was unknown. Its uncertainty is especially significant beside later confident claims of a return to family life. Neither this ending nor the court pamphlet identifies a documented final home or death date.

Royal Museums Greenwich's modern treatment similarly cautions that the 1724 book's accuracy is doubtful. It places the women aboard the sloop stolen from Nassau in August 1720 and follows Rackham's crew to their capture near Jamaica. The museum also treats men's clothing as potentially practical for work and combat rather than automatic evidence of a permanently concealed identity. Those interpretations fit the trial witnesses' distinction between clothing during attacks and at other times. They remain historical interpretations, while the witnesses' statements preserve what particular people said they saw.

An undated wood engraving in the Greenwich collection presents Anne Bonny and Mary Read as an armed pair. Catalogued as The Female Pirates and credited to F. Wentworth, it gives Bonny a gun and Read a sword. Its subtitle identifies it as derived from an older print; the catalogue supplies no creation date tying it to the 1720 proceedings. The armed pair echoes the weapons in the testimony, but the image cannot fill the gap after the pregnancy plea.

The Question

This woman joined John Rackham and Mary Read in stealing a sloop from Nassau in August 1720, then helped attack merchant ships in the West Indies. Convicted of piracy in Spanish Town that November, she obtained a stay of execution after claiming pregnancy. Who was it?

Show the answer

The Answer

Anne Bonny was the pirate tried alongside Mary Read in Spanish Town on November 28, 1720. Both women claimed pregnancy after being sentenced to death, and their executions were stayed.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the first one” you agree to Name That Culprit’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.