A Think Again Media Group publication
Name That Culprit

Victor Lustig’s counterfeit currency case ended at Alcatraz

Victor Lustig’s counterfeit currency case ended at Alcatraz

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Name That Culprit

Victor Lustig’s counterfeit currency case ended at Alcatraz

Victor Lustig was known as the 'Count', but American investigators also knew him as Robert V. Miller. His career involved numerous aliases, fraudulent sales and counterfeit currency. In 1935, a federal investigation uncovered printing plates and tens of thousands of dollars in false banknotes connected with him. He escaped from custody before trial, was recaptured in Pittsburgh and received a 20-year sentence. The criminal career that supplied tales about selling the Eiffel Tower ended in the federal prison system.

Lustig travelled between Europe and the United States and worked under names including Robert Wagner, Robert Duvall and Bert Lustig. Police photographs circulated under different identities. One appeared in the Buffalo Police Department's 1930 pocket gallery of criminals under the name Wagner. The supposed aristocratic title was another part of the public identity, helping distinguish the polished 'Count' from the less glamorous names used in official paperwork.

His most famous alleged venture concerned the Eiffel Tower in the mid-1920s. He presented himself as a government official arranging its sale for scrap. The proposal depended on the maintenance costs of a structure that had been built for the 1889 exposition and had initially been expected to stand for a limited period. The City of Paris had not authorised his offer. The scrap-dealer transaction belonged to the swindle associated with Lustig, rather than to the tower's actual ownership history.

Gustave Eiffel had died in 1923, removing the engineer most closely identified with the monument. The tower nonetheless remained in place and continued to operate. Lustig's supposed authority came from his impersonation, not from an engineering or municipal position. The sale became the episode most often attached to his name, while his American criminal work ranged through other forms of fraud. He also sold devices that he falsely claimed could duplicate banknotes. Buyers paid substantial sums for the supposed currency machines, but they did not work as advertised. These fraudulent sales formed another part of his career alongside false stocks and the actual manufacture of counterfeit money.

In 1929, Victor Lustig and William MacSherry were arrested in a case involving false stocks. They claimed an association with Al Capone's organisation, but Capone associate Jake Guzik denied knowing them. Lustig's actual contacts included figures in New York's gambling and racketeering circles. In July 1930, he was arrested with Jack Diamond and Abraham Leimas at Manhattan's President Hotel. They were released after witnesses failed to identify them.

Counterfeiting became the business that led to the decisive federal case. Lustig worked with William Watts, who produced currency plates, while the distribution of false bills brought Lustig into contact with couriers and other associates. Secret Service agents followed the growing circulation of counterfeit notes. The false currency became known to investigators as 'Lustig money', distinguishing a recognisable operation from the many unrelated offences that had previously brought him into police custody.

The 1935 investigation reached a locker in the Times Square subway station. It contained counterfeit notes and printing plates. Agents had found a key connected with Lustig, linking the travelling confidence man to material evidence of currency manufacture. His arrest put him into federal detention in New York. The case now concerned a continuing counterfeiting operation, with physical equipment and large amounts of false currency, rather than only complaints from people who had bought a fraudulent investment or machine.

Victor Lustig escaped detention on 1 September 1935. The freedom lasted only weeks. Agents traced him to Pittsburgh and arrested him again in late September. By December he and Watts were before the court. Watts cooperated with the prosecution and received a ten-year sentence. Lustig received 20 years, including punishment connected with the escape, and was sent to Alcatraz. His transfer placed him in the island penitentiary in San Francisco Bay.

He later left Alcatraz for the federal hospital at Springfield, Missouri, and died there in 1947. His death did not immediately produce the kind of publicity that had accompanied his arrests. Public confirmation came in 1949, when his brother Emil appeared in a New Jersey counterfeiting case. Questioning in that courtroom brought the earlier death of the man known as the Count back into the news.

The counterfeit currency also left an institutional record. Federal agents reported recovering more than $2 million made and passed by the organisation, while acknowledging that other notes might still remain in circulation. Victor Lustig’s exploits returned to public attention in the 1950s through crime magazines and tabloids. Biographies followed in later decades. His transfer to Alcatraz had taken place on 27 April 1936, more than a decade after the Paris episode most closely associated with his name.

The Question

What crime brought Victor Lustig the federal case that led to his 1935 prison sentence?

Show the answer

The Answer

Counterfeiting brought the federal case against Victor Lustig; agents connected him with false banknotes and currency-printing plates.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the first one” you agree to Name That Culprit’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.