A Think Again Media Group publication
Name That Culprit

The butcher who claimed a missing heir's fortune

Tichborne claimant: a name in print before a verdict

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Name That Culprit

Tichborne claimant: a name in print before a verdict

The Tichborne claimant had acquired a printed address and title while his identity was still before a court. In February 1872, Punch drew attention to Boyle's Court Guide listing a Sir Roger Tichborne at 10 Harley Road West, Brompton. The magazine treated the entry as a premature decision about the disputed inheritance. A directory could give a claim the appearance of an ordinary social fact without resolving it legally. The man using that identity was eventually identified by the criminal jury as Arthur Orton and sentenced for perjury.

The dispute began with the disappearance of Roger Charles Tichborne after he sailed from Rio de Janeiro aboard the Bella in 1854. His mother continued searching and placed advertisements overseas. A butcher known in Wagga Wagga as Thomas Castro came forward, and she accepted him. Other family members resisted his claim. The later struggle involved two distinct proceedings: a civil attempt to recover the estates and then a criminal prosecution concerning false testimony. Losing an inheritance case and being convicted of perjury were separate outcomes, reached through separate trials.

A document printed in the 1874 collection Celebrated Claimants exposes the care taken over the claimant's former identity. In a letter dated 2 April 1866 at Wagga Wagga, Thomas Castro invited an acquaintance to visit him in Hampshire under the name of Sir Roger. He specifically requested silence about Castro, his marriage and his work as a butcher. This was not simply a poorly remembered childhood detail. The letter attempted to control which recent biographical facts would accompany him into his anticipated English position. Its directions concerned information he knew and wanted withheld.

The same contemporary collection reproduces Roger's earlier written promise concerning his cousin Katherine Doughty. He proposed building a church or chapel at Tichborne, dedicated to the Virgin, if they married within the stated period. The paper had been entrusted to estate steward Gosford. The collection says he later burned it, but a copy Roger had given to his cousin was produced in court. That creates a different kind of identity evidence from a witness's impression of a face: an earlier document with particular terms and a known custodian. The Tichborne claimant's recollections could be set beside material originating before his return, rather than judged only against information circulating after the claim became public.

Punch's directory item shows how far the dispute had spread beyond those documents. The entry used the missing man's name and baronetcy without a qualification identifying the controversy. Punch mockingly presented this as contempt of court while discussing restrictions on public comment during the proceedings. The satire is evidence of a contemporary argument over the social use of the title. It is not itself a judicial ruling against the directory. The distinction matters because the dispute concerned the authority attached to apparently routine acts of naming as well as sworn evidence.

The criminal outcome was specific. Bram Stoker's later historical treatment in Famous Impostors records the verdict on 28 February 1874: the defendant was not Roger Charles Tichborne, was Arthur Orton, and had made unsupported allegations against Katherine Doughty. The sentence was fourteen years' penal servitude. Stoker also describes the unusually large body of favorable identification evidence assembled for the claim, including people connected with the family and Roger's regiment. The Tichborne claimant's success in obtaining recognition therefore did not mean that the jury ultimately accepted his identity. Personal conviction and the legal conclusion diverged.

Contemporary commentary went further than reporting that result. The May 1874 Popular Science Monthly editorial emphasized Roger's letters and journals and the mass of remembered details about his education, habits and military life. It also described financial support through bonds intended to fund the litigation. Its criticism linked the affair to public credulity and the accumulation of information by the claimant. The editorial's hostile characterizations of his mother and supporters are judgments from the controversy, rather than medical findings or additional verdicts. Its documentary importance lies in showing how promptly the legal defeat became an argument about belief and public support.

Objects made around the trial preserve another response. Brighton Museum's Willett Collection contains Randolph Caldecott's painted plaster groups of participants in the second trial, dated around 1874. Judges appear as owls; prosecution and defense counsel become a hawk and a rooster; the claimant sits as a tortoise. A separate porcelain candle-snuffer represents prosecutor Henry Hawkins, paired with a candle-shaped model of the claimant. These are physical interpretations of the proceedings, catalogued by their custodian. They record a market for recognizable courtroom characters, rather than neutral portraits establishing anyone's birth identity.

The Tichborne claimant continued trading on the disputed identity after his release in 1884, following ten years in prison. Brighton Museum's historical description records a confession sold to the People newspaper for £3,000 and then retracted, followed by music-hall appearances arguing his case. He died in 1898. The Tichborne family permitted a card bearing the claimed aristocratic name to be placed on his coffin. That inscription was a final use of the title, rather than a reversal of the criminal verdict.

The Question

In 1866, a butcher in Wagga Wagga claimed the estates and baronetcy of an heir lost at sea in 1854. The missing man's mother accepted him, but a later jury identified him as the son of a London butcher, and the court sentenced him for perjury. Who was it?

Show the answer

The Answer

Arthur Orton was the identity assigned to the claimant by the jury in the 1873-74 perjury trial. He had presented himself as Roger Tichborne, and the court sentenced him to fourteen years in prison.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the first one” you agree to Name That Culprit’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.