Han van Meegeren: the Emmaus canvas and its surviving records
Han van Meegeren's The Supper at Emmaus survives as a very tangible fraud. Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen identifies the painter as Van Meegeren, dates the canvas to 1937 and gives it inventory number St 1. It measures 130.5 centimeters wide by 118 centimeters high. The museum now places this supposed Old Master among its modern art. Its ownership history also explains why the dates 1937 and 1939 both appear in the museum's records: the purchase arrangement and the foundation's acquisition were different events.
Curator Friso Lammertse describes the financial arrangement on the museum's collection page. A contract signed on December 24, 1937, committed Willem van der Vorm to buying the painting and allowed the museum eight years to raise the money. The asking price was 520,000 guilders. Fundraising fell far short. Earlier commitments included 50,000 guilders from the Rembrandt Society and 25,000 each from Van der Vorm and J. E. F. de Kok. When the museum foundation was created in 1939, Van der Vorm forgave the outstanding amount, making the Emmaus painting its first picture. Van Meegeren's deception had therefore entered a structure of contracts, private finance and institutional ownership, as well as a gallery.
The painting offered connoisseurs something they were prepared to find. In a museum seminar published in 1968, Metropolitan Museum curator Theodore Rousseau argued that Han van Meegeren had exploited uncertainty about Vermeer's early development. Rather than duplicating a familiar mature interior, he supplied a religious composition that could fill a gap. Rousseau linked the arrangement to Caravaggio and the expectation of Italian influence on Vermeer. This was Rousseau's later explanation of the forgery's success, based on comparison with accepted paintings, rather than testimony from the moment of its sale.
Rousseau also identified particular borrowings: a disciple's head and hand recalling The Astronomer, and a jug comparable to vessels in genuine Vermeers. He noted the imitated blue color harmony, the dots of paint in the still life and the added signature. Yet he found the emotional treatment of Christ, the modeling and the exaggerated highlights unlike Vermeer's work. He also described how heating a Bakelite-like medium hardened the paint, helping it resist solvents and appear much older. Han van Meegeren could supply details that encouraged recognition while the whole composition still troubled a later observer. Rousseau's stylistic criticisms were comparative judgments; his technical description addressed manufacture.
Material research supplied a different route. A 2011 museum press release, preserved by CODART, announced analysis finding pigments in the forged painting that had only been introduced in the 19th century. The findings extended a material investigation already described by Rousseau, who had identified 19th-century cobalt blue among the forger's colors. The museum's publication brought together curator Lammertse, art historian Nadja Garthoff, conservator Michel van de Laar and scientific researcher Arie Wallert. Dirk Hannema had secured the painting amid competition with the Rijksmuseum in 1937. Modern ingredients were evidence about manufacture, independent of whether the faces or the arrangement looked persuasive to a connoisseur.
The same research also complicated the image of unanimous acceptance. A newly surfaced diary by Kröller-Müller Museum curator Willy Auping criticized another supposed Vermeer, The Washing of the Feet, which the Rijksmuseum had bought for 1.3 million guilders. Auping considered the work crude and rejected the attribution. His objection concerned that particular painting, not a laboratory examination of Emmaus. After the war, under suspicion over the sale of a supposed Vermeer to Hermann Göring, Han van Meegeren admitted making several such works. The confession and the earlier private dissent belong to different stages of the investigation.
A contemporary photograph preserves a further stage. The Rijksmuseum holds an October 1945 gelatin silver print, attributed to Koos Raucamp, showing Han van Meegeren working on Christ Among the Doctors in Amsterdam. Its attached news caption describes his offer to paint a new composition in Vermeer's style following his confession about Emmaus. According to that caption, he received a 17th-century canvas, special brushes and rare paints, and worked in the presence of witnesses. This was a demonstration of his ability to produce another picture, rather than the discovery of the original forgery in progress.
The caption says the demonstration painting was complete and depicted the young Christ teaching among the learned men. It also repeats experts' praise of its artistic quality. That approval sits beside the very accusation that had made the performance necessary. The photograph documents a painter at work; the accompanying text records how the demonstration was presented publicly in 1945. Neither can make a modern pigment old. Han van Meegeren's Emmaus canvas remained physically the same object through purchase, confession and reattribution, while its maker's name, historical date and institutional meaning changed completely.
- Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, The Supper at Emmaus collection record and curator comments — www.boijmans.nl
- Theodore Rousseau, The Stylistic Detection of Forgeries, Metropolitan Museum Bulletin, February 1968 — resources.metmuseum.org
- Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, 2011 research announcement preserved by CODART — www.codart.nl
- Rijksmuseum, Koos Raucamp photograph and original October 1945 news caption, RP-F-2005-10 — www.rijksmuseum.nl