A Think Again Media Group publication
Name That Culprit

The bank robber who slipped out of a guarded jail

John Dillinger: a stolen car, a stakeout diagram and a plaster cast

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Updated · Name That Culprit

John Dillinger: a stolen car, a stakeout diagram and a plaster cast

John Dillinger's escape from Crown Point on 3 March 1934 changed the legal reach of the pursuit. After leaving the Indiana jail, he took the sheriff's car into Illinois. The Bureau's case history identifies that interstate journey in a stolen vehicle as a violation of the National Motor Vehicle Theft Act. A federal complaint and indictment followed. The car mattered because it supplied a federal offence, beyond the state murder charge for which he had been held.

The Brownsville Herald of 4 March carried a front-page dispatch describing the escape while investigators were still reconstructing it. Its headline centred on a toy pistol, and the report said Dillinger had whittled a broom handle into the shape of a gun. It named fellow escapee Herbert Youngblood and described officers across the Midwest looking for the sheriff's sedan. The wooden-pistol detail was therefore circulating immediately after the breakout, rather than first appearing decades later in a screen portrayal.

The same report described Sheriff Lillian Holley and prosecutor Robert G. Estill conducting an inquiry, with Indiana state authorities assisting. It also relayed reported sightings from Illinois, including one based on a petrol-station attendant's identification from a photograph. Those were leads being transmitted during a search, not a continuous record of the fugitives' route. The Bureau's later case history uses qualified wording about the weapon: Dillinger subsequently claimed it was wooden. That distinction leaves the material of the initial escape weapon less certain than the theft and interstate movement of the car.

Dillinger had reached Crown Point through an earlier arrest outside Indiana. On 25 January 1934, police captured him and members of his gang in Tucson, Arizona. He was returned to Indiana under escort and held on a charge arising from the killing of East Chicago police officer William O'Malley during a bank robbery. That transfer explains why John Dillinger was inside an Indiana county jail when the famous escape occurred. The later federal pursuit followed a new offense committed after he left that custody.

Accounts of the weapon were divided from the beginning. Deputy Ernest Blunk maintained that Dillinger used a real pistol, while other accounts described a carved imitation. Sam Cahoon, a jail trusty taken hostage, also believed the gun had been fashioned from wood. These are identifiable versions of the breakout, rather than a single uncontested description of the object. The disagreement helps explain the caution in the Bureau's later wording. The vehicle's theft and movement across a state boundary supplied the federal case regardless of which weapon account a reader accepts.

By July, a more specific tip brought the investigators to Chicago theatres. The Bureau's presentation of a handwritten diagram from the Dillinger file identifies the positions of roughly 20 men at the Biograph and across the street. Outside the box office, letters A, B and C mark a companion, Dillinger and the informant. The drawing is a record of placement around a particular building, with people reduced to positions and labels at the expected point of contact.

The accompanying agency history identifies the informant as Anna Sage, a friend of Dillinger's girlfriend Polly Hamilton. She met Purvis and Samuel Cowley on 21 July, hoping for reward money and help against deportation to Romania. She named the Biograph or the Marbro as possible destinations, so both were watched. On the following evening, she telephoned to identify the Biograph. When John Dillinger emerged with the women, Purvis lit a cigar as a signal. The Bureau states that Dillinger reached for his pistol and agents fired, killing him.

John Dillinger's death on 22 July left a further physical object with an unusually commercial origin. The Bureau's artefact catalogue identifies a death mask made 12 hours later at the Cook County Morgue by Harold May of the Reliance Dental Manufacturing Company. May intended to demonstrate the quality of the company's plaster. The catalogue also reproduces a description from the case files of crowds seeking admission to view the body, with the resulting confusion continuing for several days.

Police departments asked the Bureau for copies of the mask. It declined to undertake the burden of producing them, but later allowed officers attending the FBI National Academy to cast their own as part of forensic modelling studies. The catalogue explains why numerous copies survived and why objects later offered as originals require caution. The mask thus belongs to the immediate handling of John Dillinger's remains and the later training use of a cast. It has a different provenance from the search reports, the stolen-car charge and the diagram of the fatal stakeout.

The Question

This Depression-era gangster escaped from a heavily guarded jail in Crown Point, Indiana, in March 1934 without firing a shot. That July, agents caught up with him outside Chicago's Biograph Theater. Who was it?

Show the answer

The Answer

John Dillinger escaped from the Crown Point jail on March 3, 1934. Accounts disagreed about whether his pistol was real or made of wood, but his escape without firing a shot is the distinctive clue.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the first one” you agree to Name That Culprit’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.