Baby Face Nelson: the bank file and the deaths at Barrington
Baby Face Nelson was the criminal alias of Lester Joseph Gillis, a Chicago bank robber whose final pursuit ended at Barrington, Illinois, on 27 November 1934. The surviving material includes accounts of his early robberies, a contemporary newspaper photograph and official records of the agents killed during the pursuit. Together they connect the familiar nickname to named associates, particular investigations and three deaths following a brief exchange of gunfire, rather than to an anonymous figure in a gangster photograph.
The Bureau's case history dates his escape from custody to 17 February 1932, while guards were returning him to Joliet after proceedings on another bank-robbery charge. He went through Reno to Sausalito, where he met John Paul Chase. The same history places Nelson, Helen Gillis and Chase with the Dillinger gang in April 1934. It distinguishes that documented partnership from its more tentative suggestion that Nelson might have formed an earlier connection with the gang.
Before the bank robberies, Nelson was associated with tire thieves and the movement of illicit alcohol around Chicago. His work at a local filling station brought him into contact with a group known as the strippers. The later criminal partnership with Dillinger was therefore one stage in a longer career involving theft, bootlegging and armed robbery. Baby Face Nelson's youthful appearance supplied the nickname, while his associates also called him Jimmy. These names belong to the same man rather than to separate members of a gang.
The robberies became more ambitious in 1930. Accounts identify an attack on magazine executive Charles Richter's home and another on Lottie Brenner Von Buelow's bungalow, both involving substantial jewellery losses. The group became known in newspaper coverage as the Tape Bandits because victims were bound during the home invasions. Later that year, a teller identified Nelson after the Itasca State Bank robbery. The incidents connect the later fugitive with specific victims and locations, rather than treating his entire criminal career as an extension of the Dillinger gang.
The spring pursuit had already become lethal. The Bureau places Baby Face Nelson at Little Bohemia in Wisconsin when agents moved against the Dillinger group on 22 April 1934. After leaving the lodge, he forced his way into a nearby home with hostages. When agents W. Carter Baum and J. C. Newman arrived with a local constable, Nelson approached their car and fired, killing Baum. The case history identifies a particular victim and encounter, beyond the broader label of bank robber. On 23 June, Attorney General Homer S. Cummings offered a reward for Nelson's capture or information leading to arrest.
In November, the pursuit converged on a car carrying Nelson, his wife and Chase. The Bureau's later reconstruction describes agents spotting the group in Wisconsin and obtaining its registration number. Another pair of agents encountered them on the highway; gunfire damaged Nelson's radiator. Samuel Cowley, who was directing the search, and Herman Hollis then reached the slowing vehicle near Barrington. Nelson turned off Northwest Highway at the entrance to a park, where he and Chase opened fire as the agents stopped.
The agency's reconstruction places the cars about 150 feet apart and the exchange at less than five minutes. Helen Gillis took shelter in a ditch rather than participating in the shooting. Nelson suffered wounds but continued firing; Hollis was killed and Cowley mortally wounded. The preserved image of Hollis's cancelled credentials, reproduced with that history, belongs to the administrative aftermath of the death. It identifies the lost officer as a Bureau employee, beyond his place in a dramatic retelling of the gun battle.
Cowley's official memorial supplies a precise distinction in timing. Hollis died on 27 November, while Cowley died the following morning. Nelson died on the evening of the shooting. Chase survived and was subsequently captured, convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment. The men did not all die at the roadside. The memorial records the two agents' fatal injuries and separates the exchange of fire from the later deaths and criminal proceedings that followed it.
The El Paso Herald-Post of 30 November printed a photograph of Nelson's body in a Niles Center undertaking parlour. Its caption identified police chief A. C. Stolberg and highway policeman Bill Mandernack behind the body, alongside the undertaker. Separate pictures below identified Cowley and Hollis. The caption tied the recovered body to the Barrington wounds and named local officers involved in finding it. That contemporary presentation joins municipal police, federal agents and the dead fugitive within one piece of published evidence.
The photograph, memorial and later histories preserve different parts of the pursuit. A caption identifies people around a recovered body, a memorial records an agent's death, and a case history reconstructs the encounters leading to the gunfire. Baby Face Nelson's name connects them, while their separate purposes explain why each supplies a different kind of detail.
- FBI: Lester Gillis (Baby Face Nelson) — February 1932 escape, Dillinger association and Little Bohemia — www.fbi.gov
- FBI: Firefight on Highway 12 (2009) — agency reconstruction and Herman Hollis’s cancelled credentials — archives.fbi.gov
- FBI Wall of Honor: Samuel P. Cowley — official record of fatal injuries and death on November 28, 1934 — www.fbi.gov
- El Paso Herald-Post, November 30, 1934, p. 1 — Nelson mortuary photograph and caption identifying recovery officers; UNT Libraries digitisation — texashistory.unt.edu
- Baby Face Nelson: nickname and the early Chicago robberies — en.wikipedia.org