Elmyr de Hory: the museum drawing behind the famous forger
Elmyr de Hory reached Harvard's Fogg Art Museum under another name. In June 1955, Agnes Mongan bought A Lady with Flowers and Pomegranates as a Henri Matisse drawing for $325. The transaction took place by mail with E. Raynal of Miami, a seller she had never met. A museum purchase, subsequent correspondence and a curator's later recollection preserve a more detailed trail than the glamorous image of a painter impersonating modern masters. The first difficulty was that the drawing looked convincing enough to enter the collection.
Raynal acknowledged the museum's payment and offered loans from his collection for a summer exhibition. Four more drawings arrived in July: two attributed to Modigliani, one to Renoir and another to Matisse. Mongan's 1968 letter to Clifford Irving, reproduced by Harvard Magazine, recalled immediate doubts about the Renoir and rejection of the Modiglianis after study. The Fogg returned the loans without confronting Raynal. Mongan still considered the purchased Matisse genuine, and the museum reproduced it on a postcard. Suspicion about a seller's other pictures did not instantly settle the attribution of the first purchase.
Emily Rauh Pulitzer later described her own involvement in a signed letter published in 2004. While preparing an exhibition of modern drawings, she spoke to a dealer about borrowing a Picasso. He also offered a Matisse and warned her that works with a Raynal provenance were forged. That was the history of ownership attached to the Fogg drawing. Pulitzer recalled that Mongan and professor Frederick Deknatel had accepted it. Pierre Matisse, the artist's son and a dealer himself, also accepted a photograph until she disclosed its provenance. The warning changed the evidentiary context of a persuasive image.
Pulitzer then assembled photographs of Raynal drawings and works traceable to Matisse. She connected the imitations to a specific published sequence: the artist's burst of drawing in 1941 and 1942, discussed by Alfred Barr in his 1951 book. Almost 200 examples had appeared in 1943. Her conclusion was that Elmyr de Hory extended this earlier sequence and dated his additions 1944. The proposed chronology made them plausible continuations of an established body of work. Comparison therefore joined visual resemblance to publication history, instead of depending solely on an expert's immediate impression.
The broader trading pattern made the false identity useful. Elmyr de Hory was a Hungarian-born painter who sold imitations of Picasso, Matisse, Modigliani and Renoir after World War II. He used several aliases, including Louis Cassou and Joseph Dory, as well as E. Raynal. Sales by mail helped separate the pictures from personal contact with their maker. His purported family collection and aristocratic background supplied an explanation for possessing works by celebrated artists. Those claims were part of his sales persona, rather than reliable documentation of the objects' origins.
Dealers subsequently widened the market. Fernand Legros and Réal Lessard sold de Hory's work while he lived on Ibiza, and the participants gave conflicting versions of their financial dealings. That distinction matters when considering his later celebrity: the painter's own description of his role was also a statement by someone with a direct interest in the distribution of responsibility. The museum correspondence offers a narrower, independently located sequence of a purchase, further loans, doubts and investigation.
Cinema supplied another surviving encounter with Elmyr de Hory. Simon Callow's study for Sight and Sound traces F for Fake to François Reichenbach and Richard Drewett's 1970 BBC documentary Elmyr: The True Picture? Reichenbach initially invited Orson Welles to narrate that production. Welles declined but became interested in unused material and arranged to reshape it. He filmed additional scenes with de Hory on Ibiza and conversations with Reichenbach in Paris. The footage was therefore assembled from work made by different filmmakers for different purposes.
The project's direction changed when Clifford Irving's supposed Howard Hughes autobiography was exposed as fraudulent in January 1972. Irving was already de Hory's biographer. Welles could now place the forger beside a biographer implicated in a separate deception. Callow describes editing as the engine of the resulting F for Fake, with new filming responding to the developing montage. This production history explains why de Hory's screen presence belongs to an authored cinematic construction, rather than a continuous, unmediated interrogation about individual paintings.
Geoff Andrew, discussing the BFI's rerelease, identifies documentary material, archive footage, photographs and newly filmed scenes within that construction. Welles also incorporated his own public identity and history of illusion. The film expanded from a particular forgery business into a meditation on authorship and expertise. The Fogg material remains more specific: a named drawing, a recorded price, a seller's alias, rejected loans and a curator's comparative research. Together they show how de Hory's celebrity grew from a trade that depended on famous signatures, while the identification of one false Matisse required patient attention to its less celebrated paper trail.
- Harvard Magazine, Christopher Reed, Wrong (2004): Fogg purchase and Agnes Mongan's 1968 letter to Clifford Irving — www.harvardmagazine.com
- Harvard Magazine, Cambridge 02138 (November 2004): signed firsthand letter by Emily Rauh Pulitzer — www.harvardmagazine.com
- Sight and Sound, Simon Callow, Hey presto: F for Fake and the invention of the essay film — www.bfi.org.uk
- British Film Institute, Geoff Andrew, F for Fake: all's well that ends with Welles (2012) — www.bfi.org.uk
- Wikipedia, Elmyr de Hory: aliases, dealers and postwar forgery business — en.wikipedia.org