A Think Again Media Group publication
Name That Culprit

The highwayman's identity exposed by a prison letter

Dick Turpin: the handwriting and horse marks behind the York conviction

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Name That Culprit

Dick Turpin: the handwriting and horse marks behind the York conviction

Dick Turpin faced the York assizes on March 22, 1739, under an identity that had already begun to unravel. He had lived in Yorkshire as John Palmer, buying, selling, and exchanging horses. A prison letter connected that name with Richard Turpin of Essex. The prosecution then assembled a different chain of identification around stolen animals: their owners, distinctive markings, purchasers, and the people who kept them. Thomas Kyll's contemporary printed trial preserves these practical details behind a career later associated with a spectacular ride to York.

The pamphlet's preliminary narrative places Palmer at Brough, North Cave, and Welton. He repeatedly traveled into Lincolnshire and returned with several horses to sell or exchange. His immediate trouble was smaller than a highway robbery. After shooting his landlord's cockerel, he threatened a neighbor who objected. Magistrates required sureties for good behavior; his refusal led to confinement at Beverley in October 1738. Inquiries into his movements and occupation then brought horse theft into view. Dick Turpin's local standing among hunting companions had not prevented neighbors from reporting him.

A letter from York Castle made his assumed identity vulnerable. James Smith testified that he had known Turpin since childhood and had taught him to form letters for about nine months. At a post office, Smith recognized the handwriting on a letter whose intended recipient, Turpin's brother-in-law, had declined to pay the postage. The York postmark mattered because it connected the familiar hand with a distant prison. Once the letter was opened before a magistrate, its signature under the assumed name linked the Yorkshire prisoner with Smith's Essex acquaintance.

Smith subsequently identified the prisoner in person. Edward Saward, another Essex acquaintance, also recognized him. Kyll's transcript records initial denials followed by an admission that his name was Richard Turpin. He explained Palmer as his mother's maiden name and said debts had driven him to use it. The identification did not rest on handwriting alone: the intercepted letter prompted further inquiry, and people who knew him supplied recognition. That sequence is more specific than a sudden discovery based solely on a famous criminal's appearance.

The horse evidence was equally concrete. Thomas Creasey of Heckington testified that his mare and foal had disappeared the previous August. His search involved hired assistance and advertisements in market towns. News of animals at Brough eventually took him to Ferriby, where Richard Grassby kept a mare bought from the prisoner. Before seeing her, Creasey described her distinguishing features. The black mare was blind in one eye and had identifying white markings and a brand. He said he had raised her and known her for 10 years.

A purchaser, Captain Dawson, connected the mare and foal with the prisoner through the transaction by which he acquired them. Dick Turpin claimed he had bought them from a man named Whitehead near Heckington. He sought more time for defense witnesses, but none appeared. The jury convicted him. A second indictment concerned Creasey's black gelding, another animal identified through ownership and possession. A constable testified to the prisoner's connection with that horse. The second conviction was therefore a separate horse-theft judgment, rather than an additional conviction for a highway robbery.

Family intervention followed the verdicts. The pamphlet reproduces John Turpin's March 29, 1739, letter describing an appeal to Colonel Watson for his son's transportation instead of execution; he said he would give £100 if he had it. That appeal did not secure the requested outcome. The later Dictionary of National Biography dates Dick Turpin's hanging at York to April 7, 1739. Its biography also traces the much later association between Turpin and the celebrated London-to-York ride, connecting the older riding story with another highwayman, John Nevison.

William Harrison Ainsworth's 1834 novel Rookwood gave Dick Turpin a different kind of horse. Its ride to York and Black Bess episode belong to fiction, not to the assize testimony about Creasey's animals. Ainsworth's later preface describes the composition of the ride and his attraction to highwayman adventure. The contrast is sharp: the criminal proceedings turned on ownership, sale, and recognizable physical defects; the novel made a horse's speed and endurance central to the outlaw's appeal. These are different events with different evidentiary status.

Surviving theatrical merchandise shows that fictional image entering ordinary entertainment. London Museum holds an 1835–1837 print of the actor S. Foster as Dick Turpin on horseback, made by Martin Skelt. Such sheets could be colored and decorated with tinsel at home. Another museum object, an 1890 toy-theatre envelope for Dick Turpin; or, The Death of Bonny Black Bess, carries the equine drama into a later generation. The envelope was issued by Andrews and Company in St Luke's, London, for a paper-theatre production.

The Question

This English highwayman moved to Yorkshire under an assumed identity in 1737. A letter written from York Castle revealed who he was, and he was convicted on two charges of horse theft in March 1739. Who was it?

Show the answer

The Answer

Dick Turpin was the highwayman whose prison letter exposed his identity. He had used the alias John Palmer in Yorkshire before being convicted of horse theft and executed in York.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the first one” you agree to Name That Culprit’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.