A Think Again Media Group publication
Name That Culprit

The soap seller whose prizes stayed in the gang

Soapy Smith: soap prizes and a saloon's paper trail

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Name That Culprit

Soapy Smith: soap prizes and a saloon's paper trail

Soapy Smith advertised a saloon while directing a network of confidence schemes. A notice from the Skaguay News of 7 June 1898 survives in the National Park Service's documentation of Jeff. Smith's Parlors. It anchors his business to a contemporary newspaper and a particular building, rather than to the later tourist image of a frontier outlaw. Two early books supply different perspectives on the man behind that frontage: Jack Black recalled encountering him in Denver, while Frederick Palmer described his power in gold-rush Skagway in a volume published in 1899.

Black's memoir You Can't Win, published in 1926, describes the soap performance in practical terms. Soapy Smith wrapped banknotes around bars in sight of prospective customers, then drew a crowd with his sales pitch. Black remembered nickel soap sold for fifty cents or a dollar, with supposed prizes of five or ten dollars. Accomplices competed noisily with ordinary buyers and obtained the packages containing money. This recollection identifies the essential arrangement: real banknotes and a visible apparent winner created confidence, while coordinated participants prevented the paying public from receiving the displayed prizes.

Black also recalled a less flattering encounter for himself. He and his associate took a dice concession at a Denver gambling house, committing $2,000 of their combined $3,000 to the bankroll. Soapy Smith won the operating money in three successive plays. Black refused to risk his remaining $500, forcing them to stop. The episode places Smith within a gambling economy where thieves could themselves lose large sums. It is personal testimony by someone describing his own loss, distinct from the staged success of a planted customer at a soap sale.

The memoir's portrait is not neutral admiration. Black characterized Smith as a gambler and confidence man, recounting both large wins and large losses. He linked soap selling to occasions when Smith needed money after gambling reverses. That sequence gives the street performance a financial role as well as a nickname: it was a way to replenish funds by controlling the distribution of a supposedly uncertain reward. Black's perspective comes from the criminal milieu, and the recollections were published decades after the events. Their detail is valuable without making every remembered exchange independently verifiable.

Palmer's In the Klondyke provides a near-contemporary view of the Alaska operation. He described a town crowded with gambling and dance halls, where some newcomers lost their cash and eventually sold their outfits to return home. He called Smith a self-appointed mayor and commander of an army of disorder. That language expresses the observer's judgment about informal power; it does not establish election to municipal office. Palmer located formal enforcement in a United States commissioner and a handful of deputy marshals, while portraying their response to disorder as ineffective.

The physical headquarters is more tightly bounded in the property record. According to the Park Service's title and tax research, the First Bank of Skaguay owned the building until 1900. After the bank moved to larger premises, Frank Clancy sublet it, perhaps in partnership with Smith. The uncertainty about the partnership remains part of the reconstruction. The bank's former office and Smith's saloon were successive uses of the same structure. His criminal occupation of it should not be mistaken for ownership of the bank or legal title to the property.

Soapy Smith changed the building's public face. The small wooden structure on Sixth Avenue originally had a central door between two windows. During the saloon conversion, the doorway moved right and the windows left, apparently to accommodate the bar. Siding, a cornice and projecting signs reinforced its commercial frontage, and bars covered the windows. The National Park Service dates the parlor's opening to May 1898. The June advertisement therefore belongs within a brief operating period, supported by a surviving 1898 photograph from the Charles Bunnell collection.

The reported telegraph fraud offered another apparently ordinary business service. Customers paid to send messages from an office whose wires ended at the wall. Smith's men also adopted respectable roles, including reporter or clergyman, to befriend newcomers, assess their resources and steer them toward dishonest enterprises or gambling. Born Jefferson Randolph Smith II, the man known as Soapy combined the street demonstrator's staged reassurance with a network of plausible intermediaries. The individual transaction could look routine while the surrounding people and premises worked together against the customer.

The saloon's use as Smith's headquarters ended with his death in the gunfight of 8 July 1898. The building survived through other businesses and later became a museum in 1935. Its short association with Smith is consequently more precise than his enduring reputation suggests. Black's remembered soap sales expose the managed payout; Palmer's contemporary observations describe intimidation and weak enforcement; the advertisement, photograph and property research locate the saloon in the town's commercial life. Those records place a confidence man's methods beside the practical organization that gave them reach.

The Question

A frontier con artist sold soap supposedly hiding cash prizes, but sleight of hand directed the money to his accomplices. His operations expanded from Colorado to Skagway, where a fake telegraph office had wires that stopped at the wall. Who was it?

Show the answer

The Answer

Soapy Smith was the con artist born Jefferson Randolph Smith II. His prize soap racket used gang members as apparent winners, and he later ran criminal operations in Denver, Creede, and Skagway.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the first one” you agree to Name That Culprit’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.