Clifford Irving: the Hughes manuscript and the money trail
Clifford Irving sold McGraw-Hill a relationship as well as a manuscript. The proposed autobiography depended on Howard Hughes having chosen him, spoken to him and authorized the result. On 7 January 1972, Hughes denied meeting or corresponding with Irving during a telephone conference with seven journalists. Their end of the exchange was televised. The supposed collaboration now had a public contradiction from the man whose name supplied its commercial value. The subsequent court proceedings preserved something less elusive than access to a recluse: contracts, payments, sworn testimony and orders concerning the manuscript.
Irving worked with Richard Suskind, who researched Hughes in news archives. Forged correspondence supplied the apparent connection between that research and Hughes himself. Irving approached the publisher with the claim that Hughes admired his book about art forger Elmyr de Hory and wanted his help with an autobiography. Signatures on the publishing agreements were also forged. These documents performed different jobs. Letters suggested a private invitation; signatures appeared to convert that invitation into an enforceable publishing arrangement. Clifford Irving could assemble authentic information about Hughes without possessing the personal authorization he was selling.
The federal district court's June 1972 opinion in Irving v. Gray itemizes McGraw-Hill's payments during 1971. The total was $765,000: $100,000 in advance royalties, $15,000 for expenses and $650,000 in checks payable to Hughes for his supposed participation. Of the last amount, $466,250 reached a Swiss Banking Corporation deposit through Edith Irving using assumed names or false identification papers. The money did not reach Hughes. Those categories matter because the largest payment purported to compensate the billionaire, rather than merely paying Irving for writing about him.
Edith's lawyers described her role as that of a courier when contesting the resulting tax demands. Judge Frankel pointed to Clifford Irving's sworn grand-jury testimony that $85,000 from McGraw-Hill had entered her brokerage holdings. He declined to accept the lawyers' description without direct supporting evidence. The opinion also records guilty pleas to federal conspiracy and state larceny and conspiracy charges. It is a contemporary judicial record of financial participation, although the proceeding itself concerned tax collection rather than the original criminal adjudication.
Detailed information had helped make the manuscript persuasive. TIME's reporting of 21 February 1972 compared it with material prepared by James Phelan for Noah Dietrich, Hughes's longtime chief aide. The magazine concluded that substantial passages overlapped. That was a contemporary journalistic comparison, distinct from the courts' findings about payments and authorization. It explains how convincing information and fraudulent attribution could coexist: accurate details about a life do not establish that its subject dictated them to a particular collaborator.
The publication litigation supplies another sequence of documents. Rosemont Enterprises, claiming exclusive contractual rights to Hughes material, began its action on 13 January 1972. On 20 January, the parties agreed to withhold publication while authenticity was investigated. February orders restricted publication by Time Incorporated and impounded the manuscript and related papers. After Irving publicly acknowledged that the purported biography was inauthentic, a further injunction followed on 30 May. These dates are preserved in the appellate court's later Rosemont v. Irving decision.
The federal appeal in Irving v. Gray followed the money beyond the publishing contract. On 4 February 1972, while grand juries were investigating, the Internal Revenue Service demanded immediate payment of taxes for 1971 and levied on securities held at Merrill Lynch. The service assessed a combined $512,111 against the Irvings and Suskind. The brokerage forwarded $91,322.92 from Edith's and Suskind's holdings. Clifford Irving and the other plaintiffs sought to have those funds restored for distribution among creditors, including McGraw-Hill and their lawyers.
The Second Circuit rejected that attempt in June 1973. Its decision distinguished the immediate protection of tax revenue from the eventual calculation of the taxpayers' full liability. The plaintiffs could pursue refund procedures after filing returns; their objections did not entitle them to stop collection through this lawsuit. The figures consequently describe several different things: money advanced by a publisher, money collected by the government and tax liabilities asserted by the government. They cannot simply be added together as separate proceeds of the deception.
A final dispute returned to the same manuscript in 1975, when Irving arranged publication in Spain as fiction. Rosemont sought a broader prohibition, but the New York appellate court upheld the refusal to expand the injunction. It distinguished publishing the text as an authorized Hughes autobiography from publishing a work expressly labeled fictional. Clifford Irving's fraudulent undertaking had rested on the first representation. Removing that representation changed the publication dispute, while leaving the original unauthorized payments and fabricated collaboration intact.
- U.S. District Court, Irving v. Gray, 344 F. Supp. 567, 15 June 1972 — openjurist.org
- Second Circuit, Irving v. Gray, 479 F.2d 20, 1 June 1973 — openjurist.org
- New York Appellate Division, Rosemont Enterprises v. Irving, 49 A.D.2d 445, 2 December 1975 — openjurist.org
- TIME, The Fabulous Hoax of Clifford Irving, 21 February 1972 — time.com
- Wikipedia, Clifford Irving: correspondence, announcement and Hughes telephone conference — en.wikipedia.org
- HISTORY, Howard Hughes Breaks His Silence: recorded statement, January 1972 — www.history.com