Belle Starr’s horse-theft conviction and the life behind the nickname
Belle Starr became famous as the 'Bandit Queen', but her documented conviction was for horse theft. In 1883, Judge Isaac Parker's federal court sentenced her to a year in the Detroit House of Correction. Her life connected Missouri, Texas and Indian Territory, and she associated with several outlaws. The expansive image of a woman commanding spectacular raids grew through cheap fiction and later screen versions, especially after her death in 1889.
She was born Myra Maybelle Shirley in Jasper County, Missouri, in 1848. Her family moved to Carthage, where her father became an innkeeper. Her father, John Shirley, was also a slaveholder; her mother was Elizabeth Hatfield Shirley. The family called their daughter May. During the Civil War, the Shirleys supported the Confederate side and had connections with irregular fighters. Her brother Bud joined such a group. The war disrupted the family's home, and by 1864 they had moved to Scyene, near Dallas, Texas. She was one of six children and the only daughter. She probably attended the Carthage Female Academy and a private school called Cravens.
In 1866, members of the Younger family and Jesse James used the Shirley home as a hiding place. Later that year, Belle married Jim Reed, whom she had known in Missouri. They had two children, Rosie Lee, usually called Pearl, and James Edwin. The family lived for a time in Indian Territory and also went to California. Rosie Lee was born in 1868 and James Edwin on 22 February 1871. Reed faced a murder charge before the family left Indian Territory for California.
Reed became involved in robberies and associated with outlaw groups operating across Texas, Arkansas and Indian Territory. Belle eventually left him. He died while resisting arrest in 1874. A later relationship with Bruce Younger also entered accounts of her life, although its legal status is uncertain. In June 1880, she married Sam Starr in the Cherokee Nation. The ceremony took place on 5 June 1880.
Belle Starr and Sam established their home at Youngers' Bend, near present-day Eufaula, Oklahoma. Their cabin stood on communal tribal land in the Cherokee Nation. Outlaws used it as a refuge during the early 1880s. The horse-theft case brought the couple into the jurisdiction of the federal court at Fort Smith, Arkansas. Her sentence comprised two six-month terms at the Detroit House of Correction in Michigan.
The Fort Smith court dealt with a broad range of defendants and offences. Women appeared before it as witnesses, complainants and accused people. Female defendants were not a novelty, and charges included illegal liquor sales as well as more serious crimes. Some women also worked within the court's administration. Florence Hammersly served as a deputy clerk, while Kate Sandels worked in the district attorney's office. The federal court had no female district attorneys, commissioners or marshals during this period.
Conditions in the Fort Smith jail attracted public criticism during this same period. In 1885, journalist Anna Dawes published an account of the poor accommodation under the title A United States Prison. It was reprinted in the Congressional Record and helped bring federal funds for a new jail. Women also visited prisoners, brought food and flowers and pressed for changes. Those activities formed part of the court's social world alongside trials and sentencing.
Belle Starr was charged again in 1886 and the case ended without a conviction: the Texas State Historical Association records a horse-theft charge that ended in acquittal, while the National Park Service describes a hold-up charge dismissed for lack of evidence. Sam Starr died that year. She later lived with Jim July, who also used the Starr name. On 3 February 1889 she was killed near the Canadian River. No one was convicted. She was buried at Youngers' Bend, where her daughter later placed a headstone decorated with a bell, a star and a horse. The memorial used visual symbols of the name by which her mother had become known.
Richard K. Fox, publisher of the National Police Gazette, helped turn Starr's regional notoriety into a widely sold story. In 1889 he issued Bella Starr, the Bandit Queen, or the Female Jesse James. It cost 25 cents and used her life loosely as the basis for popular fiction. Publication after her death placed her among the commercially successful outlaw characters circulating far beyond the communities where she had actually lived.
Film and television continued that process. Belle Starr appeared as a screen subject from the late 1920s onward and in a later production starring Elizabeth Montgomery. Fort Smith's wider history likewise supplied material for western films about deputy marshals, judges and outlaws. The courthouse itself became a filming location, including for Frank and Jesse in 1993 and the Civil War miniseries The Blue and the Gray.
- Oklahoma Historical Society, Adriana G. Schroeder — Starr, Myra Maybelle Shirley — www.okhistory.org
- Texas State Historical Association, Leon C. Metz — Starr, Myra Maybelle Shirley — www.tshaonline.org
- National Park Service, Juliet L. Galonska — Women and the federal court — www.nps.gov
- National Park Service — Fort Smith in the movies — www.nps.gov