A Think Again Media Group publication
Name That Culprit

The bootlegging boss brought down by unpaid taxes

Al Capone: the gambling records behind five tax convictions

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Updated · Name That Culprit

Al Capone: the gambling records behind five tax convictions

Al Capone became the Chicago gang's boss in 1925, after Johnny Torrio was wounded and relinquished control. His eventual tax conviction followed years of other legal proceedings. The Bureau's later history describes an earlier attempt to delay a grand-jury appearance in March 1929: lawyers submitted a physician's affidavit saying that pneumonia had confined him to bed in Miami and that travel to Chicago would endanger his health. His grand-jury appearance was rescheduled for 20 March.

Agents gathered statements placing Capone at Florida racecourses, on a flight to Bimini and on a cruise to Nassau, apparently in good health. He eventually appeared before the grand jury and was arrested for contempt when his testimony ended. A separate Philadelphia weapons conviction also brought imprisonment. Meanwhile, Treasury investigators were developing the tax case. That investigation required evidence connecting illegal business income with him, rather than relying on his notoriety or an unrelated conviction. Federal court convicted him of contempt in February 1931 and imposed six months.

A Treasury letter dated 8 July 1931 begins by recognising the enormous publicity surrounding Al Capone. Its agents also cautioned that newspaper attention did not make every sensational allegation reliable. The practical obstacle was his use of cash and the scarcity of conventional financial traces. The investigators reported difficulty finding securities purchased by him or endorsed cheques. They therefore depended heavily on people who had dealt with him and his organisation, people whose fear or loyalty could obstruct testimony.

The July letter describes examining remittance sheets and deposit slips from the Pinkert State Bank covering 1924 through 1928. Investigators compiled lists of clearing cheques, recording their makers and last endorsers. They interviewed witnesses and analysed the finances of associates. By May 1930, additional agents had arrived to strengthen the investigation. The letter describes witnesses being brought to Chicago and kept under guard, alongside raids and hundreds of interviews. Financial tracing and protection of testimony formed parts of the same operation.

Frank Wilson's letter to Intelligence Unit chief Irey on 27 March 1931 shows how witnesses could connect a business to its owner. Wilson referred to an affidavit by the Reverend Hoover describing admissions made by Al Capone concerning a gambling establishment. He enclosed a statement by Cicero property dealer Chester Bragg reporting a similar admission. Wilson said the establishment's books reflected $574,000 in net profits over 24 months. The amount belonged to the business records; the admissions supplied a link to its ownership.

Other testimony in the March letter concerned access and control. Telegraph operators described a private wire room whose racing information was confidential and whose visitors were restricted. Capone was among the few permitted inside. The cashier described receiving his instruction to take charge of the money during a raid. These details supported the investigators' ownership theory in different ways: privileged access, a direct command over cash and reported admissions. Wilson presented them as grounds for proceeding, before the jury had decided the case.

His longer report of 21 December 1933 traced the gambling book itself. Police had seized it during a 1926 raid; it was passed to a revenue investigator and then lay among miscellaneous papers. Wilson described rediscovering it and comparing its entries with handwriting specimens. That work led to Leslie A. Shumway and other men who had managed or handled cash at the Hawthorne Smoke Shop in Cicero. A book without an obvious identifying label became useful through evidence connecting its entries to named employees.

Wilson located Shumway in Miami in February 1931 and obtained a sworn statement. Shumway then appeared before the grand jury, with his involvement kept secret until trial. The report treats his testimony and the gambling records as foundations for charges. It also describes protecting important witnesses from influence, tying the written figures to people who could identify the transactions.

The surviving jury verdict gives the outcome in a tightly limited form. Under consolidated cases 22852 and 23232, it finds Alphonse Capone not guilty on the former indictment. On the latter, it records guilty findings on counts one, five, nine, thirteen and eighteen, with the other counts listed as not guilty. Five convictions did not mean that every charge had succeeded. Nor did this verdict decide every act of violence or bootlegging associated with his organisation; it resolved the counts placed before that jury.

Wilson dated the guilty findings to 17 October 1931: tax evasion for 1925–1927 and failure to file for 1928–1929. Judge James H. Wilkerson imposed terms amounting to 11 years, a $50,000 fine and prosecution costs. Those specific findings supplied the legal basis for Al Capone's confinement.

The Question

This Prohibition-era boss ran a criminal organization in Chicago from 1925 to 1931 and cultivated a public image through charity donations. A conviction on five tax counts brought an eleven-year sentence. Who was it?

Show the answer

The Answer

Al Capone was the co-founder and boss of the Chicago Outfit. His 1931 conviction on five tax counts ended his reign as a crime boss.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the first one” you agree to Name That Culprit’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.