A Think Again Media Group publication
Name That Culprit

The colony that existed on certificates alone

Poyais scheme: a printed country, a banknote and a bond

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Name That Culprit

Poyais scheme: a printed country, a banknote and a bond

The Poyais scheme offered more than a place on a map. Gregor MacGregor's promotion combined settlement literature, financial securities and a currency bearing his authority as Cazique. An 1822 guide presented the territory as a practical destination for emigrants; a later banknote owner transcribed the names printed on its money. The land along Central America's Mosquito Coast was real. The prosperous settlement offered to emigrants was another matter. The surviving paper is especially revealing because it shows how travel, government and credit were made to appear parts of the same established enterprise.

The title page of Sketch of the Mosquito Shore identifies Thomas Strangeways as a captain in the First Native Poyer Regiment and aide-de-camp to MacGregor. It dedicates the volume to the Cazique and says it is intended chiefly for settlers. The booksellers are William Blackwood in Edinburgh and T. Caddell in London; the date is 1822. These are declarations of the publication's own allegiance and intended use. Its military title and dedication place the promotional enterprise inside the book, rather than leaving its relationship to MacGregor concealed behind an apparently detached description.

The guide's geographical text names Black River as Rio Tinto and places a town called Poyais, described as the capital, about forty miles inland on its left bank. It combines that statement with coastal bearings, river distances and navigability. Such precision creates a striking contrast with the absence of the developed destination encountered by emigrants. Coordinates and sailing information could locate a real stretch of coast while the text supplied an unsupported urban promise. The geographical framework made the settlement claim specific, but specificity was not an inspection of what had actually been built.

Another trace of the Poyais scheme concerns the money. In a later issue of Notes and Queries, A. C. Willis reported owning a Poyais banknote engraved by an Edinburgh firm. He transcribed its place and incomplete date as St. Joseph, 182-, and identified the issuing institution as the Bank of Poyais, acting under MacGregor's authority. This is an owner's description of an object, rather than a contemporary audit of a functioning bank. Its significance lies in the vocabulary printed on the paper: a place of issue, an issuing bank and a ruler's authorization all reinforced one another. The incomplete year gives no exact issue date for that specimen.

The exchange of ordinary money for Poyais notes appears in John Francis's Chronicles and Characters of the Stock Exchange, published in 1850. He says Bank of Poyais notes were substituted for Bank of Scotland notes on the explanation that Scottish money would not circulate there. He also records a £200,000 loan issued at eighty percent of face value. Francis wrote decades after the venture, using the language of financial disaster; his dramatic descriptions of emigrants' emotions are later narration. The Poyais scheme involved distinct mechanisms: buying a debt security, buying land and changing currency were separate transactions within the promotion.

Modern research by Damian Clavel reconstructs the loan through contracts, correspondence and market records. A 6 percent loan for £200,000 was contracted on 23 October 1822. Its 2,000 bearer bonds had nominal values of £100 and an initial price of £80. Buyers could pay £15 at delivery, followed by installments of £35 and £30. Because permanent certificates were not ready, the contractor supplied scrip carrying a conditional right to receive bonds after payment. Those details distinguish the face amount from immediate cash received and distinguish temporary subscription papers from completed securities.

Clavel also identifies James Ogilvie as both MacGregor's agent and shipper. Ogilvie held two-thirds of the temporary securities and accepted them toward payment for supplies. The ships were to carry settlers and about £16,000 in goods for construction at Black River. The Poyais scheme thus linked shipping arrangements to financial securities, rather than making every nominal pound of debt immediately available as cash.

Clavel treats the underlying territory as an Indigenous land concession and the promotion as a failed colonial project. The land was real; that did not establish the advertised town's existence. A territorial grant and an inhabited capital were different things.

The consequences became physical when emigrants landed. The Honduras Packet and Kennersley Castle carried emigrants from Britain to Black River. Their passengers had bought into a project promoted through land sales, printed descriptions and financial promises. Roughly 250 people crossed expecting the promised settlement. They found no capital of St. Joseph and faced disease while living in makeshift shelter. Survivors were eventually evacuated toward Belize, and many emigrants died. The guide, banknote and loan had each supplied a different reason to trust the same destination. None supplied the buildings, services or protection that the arrivals needed.

The Question

Beginning in 1821, a Scottish adventurer sold investors on a supposed Central American territory called Poyais. Settlers who sailed there found no trace in Honduras of the developed colony he had described. Who was it?

Show the answer

The Answer

Gregor MacGregor promoted the fictional territory of Poyais to British and French investors and settlers. About 250 emigrants reached Honduras in 1823 expecting his claimed colony, but found no such colony.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the first one” you agree to Name That Culprit’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.